36 people charged in fraud scheme involving staged car wrecks in the Tri-State

Published: Nov. 10, 2015 at 8:00 PM CST|Updated: Oct. 10, 2016 at 5:38 PM CDT
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

EVANSVILLE, IN (WFIE) - Prosecutors say 36 people were involved in an elaborate scheme to defraud insurance companies.

We're told three SWAT teams and over 70 officers served arrest warrants on Tuesday morning to 30 of the 36 suspects.

The indictment alleges that Michael W. Burris, Lisa K. Burris, Justin A. Burris, David B. Smitha, and others planned a series of accidents in and around Evansville between 2008 and 2014.

Prosecutors say they recruited people to participate in staged crashes, made false police reports, and then filed claims with insurance providers for "injuries" suffered.

We're told they received more than $600,000 in false insurance claims over a four year period.

"This is the largest white-collar investigation and scheme in our area, ever," said U.S. Attorney Josh J. Minkler.

According to the U.S. Attorney's Office, the Burris family would recruit someone to crash a vehicle in a remote area.

After the accident, the driver would leave the scene and other people would enter the vehicle and wait for emergency responders to arrive.

Minkler says vehicles were often loaded with three or four people to maximize insurance claims.

The indictment alleges Burris Sr. and his conspirators purposely injured the "victims."

Prosecutors say the scheme involved at least 12 crashes in Vanderburgh, Warrick, and Henderson counties. We're told two medical helicopters responded to one of the staged wrecks.

Investigators say the "victims" were also told how to act during the crash and run up medical bills through hospital stays.

Minkler says false insurance claims would be submitted and checks divided between the conspirators.

Prosecutors have been investigating the case for the past two years.

Each charge carries a maximum sentence of 20 years in prison, a $250,000 fine and three years of supervised release.

The following people were indicted:

Michael W. Burris, Sr.

Age 56

Evansville, Indiana

Lisa K. Burris

Age 53

Evansville, Indiana

David B. Smitha

Age 38

Evansville, Indiana

Justin A. Burris

Age 26

Evansville, Indiana

Amanda J. Carreno

Age 35

Evansville, Indiana

Timothy S. Ivy

Age 44

Evansville, Indiana

Michael W. Burris, Jr.

Age 30

Evansville, Indiana

Timothy P. Rice

Age 38

Evansville, Indiana

Shawn M. Wright

Age 21

Henderson, Kentucky

Jordan T. Lawrence

Age 21

Evansville, Indiana

Joshua J. Norman

Age 25

Evansville, Indiana

Shaun T. Gibson

Age 36

Evansville, Indiana

Kyle Blake Lee Smitha

Age 20

Evansville, Indiana

Thomas J. Thomas

Age 21

Evansville, Indiana

Alyssa R. Vailes

Age 22

Evansville, Indiana

Latisha L. Smith

Age 36

Evansville, Indiana

Dillon A. Williams

Age 22

Evansville, Indiana

Brooke N. Cox

Age 32

Evansville, Indiana

Brooke N. Ewers

Age 27

Evansville, Indiana

Toni J. Wilson

Age 41

Evansville, Indiana

Jerry A. McGill

Age 55

Evansville, Indiana

Benjamin W. Widick

Age 42

Evansville, Indiana

Lynn M. Smitha

Age 34

Evansville, Indiana

Phillip J. Gibson

Age 37

Chandler, Indiana

Michelle L. Stuard

Age 30

Evansville, Indiana

Ariel R. Pace

Age 24

Evansville, Indiana

Ashley N. Hines

Age 29

Evansville, Indiana

Crystal D. Uziekalla

Age 41

Evansville, Indiana

David W. Uziekalla

Age 38

Wadesville, Indiana

Tiffany L. Bowen

Age 26

Evansville, Indiana

Shawna M. Morell

Age 35

Chandler, Indiana

Jamey L. Grant

Age 27

Evansville, Indiana

Ryan Maun

Age 28

Evansville, Indiana

Mary E. Houchin

Age 36

Evansville, Indiana

Theresa A. Frank

Age 31

Boonville, Indiana

Sherry W. Greenwalt

Age 41

Evansville, Indiana

Police are still looking for six of the suspects: Jerry A. McGill, Benjamin W. Widick, Timothy S. Ivy, Ryan Maun, Shaun T. Gibson, and Sherry M. Greenwalt.

If you have information on their whereabouts, call police.

Follow us online at 14NEWS.com and on Twitter. Text NEWSAPP to 51414 or click here to download our 14 News mobile app to get breaking news alerts and the latest headlines from around the Tri-State.

Copyright 2015 WFIE. All rights reserved.