Animal cruelty sentence almost over for Vanderburgh Co. woman

New non-profit started at her address

Animal cruelty sentence almost over for Vanderburgh Co. woman

EVANSVILLE, IN (WFIE) - The Vanderburgh County woman sentenced in a 2017 animal cruelty case, seems to have plans to take in more rescue dogs.

Records show an IRS filing for a new Section 501(c) (3), or a public charity status, was approved in October.

The Vanderburgh Humane Society is already at near full capacity and yet they worry what could happen if a situation like the one in 2017 happens again.

Kendall Paul is the VHS Executive Director. She said, “Vanderburgh Humane Society, It takes a Village, Another Chance for Animals all of these agencies were affected.”

The paper work says the charity is called “Forever Home” at the same Hillview Drive address where 68 dogs were seized by animal control.

The building is a former church, still owned by Martha Crosley.

In 2016, Crosley was approved for a 501(c)(3) called “Wise Hearts" at the same address.

At the time of the seizure in 2017, she said she was trying to start an animal sanctuary.

Deputies found the dogs in very small crates and lying in feces and urine. Vanderburgh County Sheriff Dave Wedding said, “Some of them looked like they were underfed. The conditions just weren’t conducive for that large number of animals.”

According to court documents, her sentence included a period of 18 months with no new dogs. That ends Jan. 21.

Animal Control officials say Crosley passed inspections during their check ups.

The case in 2017 sparked interest from animal rescue activists who even filed a restraining order to block Crosley from getting some of her dogs back.

That civil action also claimed Crosley had not been using donations to “Wise Hearts” properly.

Five dogs had already made it back to Crosley before restraining order was granted.

The filing of a new sanctuary is something authorities hope she will not take lightly. Sheriff Dave Wedding added, “If she can pull it off, it would be beneficial to Evansville and Vanderburgh County residents. Now, I think they should keep a watchful eye on her to make sure she follows the rules and regulations she must abide by.”

Thursday the Vanderburgh County Prosecutor’s Office sent us a statement:

“Martha Crosley’s criminal case, and subsequent terms of probation set in place by a judge, are complete at the end of January. The Vanderburgh County Prosecutor’s Office, along with law enforcement officers, animal control officers, and animal rights activists, need lawmakers to toughen up the penalties related to animal cruelty cases in the state of Indiana.”

Animal cruelty sentence almost over for Vanderburgh Co. woman, new non-profit started at her address

Copyright 2019 WFIE. All rights reserved.