Misleading Craigslist ad makes one home seller feel uneasy - Tri-State News, Weather & Sports

Misleading Craigslist ad makes one home seller feel uneasy

NEWBURGH, IN (WFIE) -

Selling a home shouldn't be this difficult.

That's what we're hearing from a Newburgh family receiving unexpected and unwelcome attention from a fake post on Craigslist.

For Melissa McCutchan, selling her home has been nothing short of a nightmare.

"I didn't know it could happen and I found out shockingly yesterday and it's been a nightmare ever since," says McCutchan.

The 'for sale' sign has been up for less than two weeks.

It's all the time it took for a fake Craigslist post, advertising the McCutchan's Newburgh home as a rental property.

"It's listed as an extremely low rental rate with all the utilities included, free trash pickup," says McCutchan. "Just too good to be true."

The fake offer has people coming by the car full.

Parents looking in windows, kids playing in the yard. 

One man even came inside.

"I thought someone was breaking into our home," says McCutchan. "I didn't know what to do. I basically told him to get out of my house and he was flabbergasted and just said that he was responding to the ad on Craigslist."

The ad asks for a security deposit and personal information, everything down to your children's names.

It's something the McCutchans realtor has seen for three years now, but Melissa, it was something she never saw coming.

"I think there needs to be something done to stop it," says McCutchan. "There has to be something done."

Both the Sheriff's department and her realtor have suggested the family stay home for now, letting people know what they've seen isn't what it looks like and for McCutchan, she just wants life back to normal.

The Warrick County Sheriff's Department couldn't comment on the problem, only saying the investigation is ongoing.

The realtor tells 14 News that she has flagged the ad on Craigslist as span and it should be taken down.

Copyright 2013 WFIE. All rights reserved.

  • LOCALMore>>

  • 14 NEWS Exclusive: Can school security and fire safety coexist?

    14 NEWS Exclusive: Can school security and fire safety coexist?

    Thursday, April 19 2018 11:21 PM EDT2018-04-20 03:21:56 GMT

    Indiana State officials are trying to figure out what to do with millions of taxpayers money to ensure children's safety in schools.  Our cameras were the only ones inside an Indianapolis meeting with law enforcement officials, politicians, educators, and the state's Department of Homeland Security. Vanderburgh County Sheriff Dave Wedding teamed up with Porter County Sheriff David Reynolds to facilitate the round table discussion. One of the biggest topics d...

    More >>

    Indiana State officials are trying to figure out what to do with millions of taxpayers money to ensure children's safety in schools.  Our cameras were the only ones inside an Indianapolis meeting with law enforcement officials, politicians, educators, and the state's Department of Homeland Security. Vanderburgh County Sheriff Dave Wedding teamed up with Porter County Sheriff David Reynolds to facilitate the round table discussion. One of the biggest topics d...

    More >>
  • Over 2k people attend Right to Life Banquet

    Over 2k people attend Right to Life Banquet

    Thursday, April 19 2018 10:11 PM EDT2018-04-20 02:11:50 GMT
    The annual pro-life event raises money and awareness to educate women and their families about abortion (WFIE)The annual pro-life event raises money and awareness to educate women and their families about abortion (WFIE)
    The annual pro-life event raises money and awareness to educate women and their families about abortion (WFIE)The annual pro-life event raises money and awareness to educate women and their families about abortion (WFIE)

    Over 2,000 people attended the Right to Life Banquet. 

    More >>

    Over 2,000 people attended the Right to Life Banquet. 

    More >>
  • Gov. Bevin in Muhlenberg Co. to visit new Opportunity Zones

    Gov. Bevin in Muhlenberg Co. to visit new Opportunity Zones

    Thursday, April 19 2018 7:56 PM EDT2018-04-19 23:56:49 GMT
    (WFIE)(WFIE)
    (WFIE)(WFIE)

    Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin is in Muhlenberg County to join federal, state, and local officials to visit newly-announced Opportunity Zones. The Kentucky Opportunity Zone Initiative gives both rural and urban areas an opportunity to strengthen and rebuild their economies, spurring investment, growth, and community development. Gov. Bevin is expected in Muhlenberg Co any minute. He’s joining federal, state and local officials to visit a newly announced Opportunity Zones. pic....

    More >>

    Kentucky Governor Matt Bevin is in Muhlenberg County to join federal, state, and local officials to visit newly-announced Opportunity Zones. The Kentucky Opportunity Zone Initiative gives both rural and urban areas an opportunity to strengthen and rebuild their economies, spurring investment, growth, and community development. Gov. Bevin is expected in Muhlenberg Co any minute. He’s joining federal, state and local officials to visit a newly announced Opportunity Zones. pic....

    More >>
Powered by Frankly