Oldest cold case in US history ends in guilty verdict - 14 News, WFIE, Evansville, Henderson, Owensboro

Oldest cold case in US history ends in guilty verdict

Posted: Updated:
ISP Director Hiram Grau addresses media on McCullough guilty verdict (Photo courtesy of the DeKalb Daily Chronicle) ISP Director Hiram Grau addresses media on McCullough guilty verdict (Photo courtesy of the DeKalb Daily Chronicle)
  • 14 Headlines

  • Thursday, May 23 2013 9:21 AM EDT2013-05-23 13:21:56 GMT
    As of 5:30 Thursday morning, a 14 News Crew is at train derailment on Oak Grove Road. Officials say a train car has come off the track and are currently waiting for a crew from Louisville to get it back
    Officials say traffic is blocked near Kight Lumber and Morgan Avenue.
  • Thursday, May 23 2013 5:03 AM EDT2013-05-23 09:03:58 GMT
    A mobile home catches fire in Henderson for the second time in just over 24 hours. It happened at 622 Graves Drive. Officials say the back of the home caught fire Tuesday night just before midnight and
    Officials say the back of the home caught fire Tuesday night just before midnight and then again around midnight Thursday morning.
  • Saturday, May 25 2013 7:33 PM EDT2013-05-25 23:33:54 GMT
    Two people were killed in a massive house fire in Muhlenberg County. That fire broke out in a house on Hazel Creek Road in the small town of Beechmont. 14 News is currently on the scene and will have
    Two people were killed in a massive house fire in Muhlenberg County. That fire broke out in a house on Hazel Creek Road in the small town of Beechmont. 14 News is currently on the scene and will have
Sycamore, IL (WFIE) -

What is to be believed as the oldest cold case that's been brought to trial in U.S. history wrapped up with a guilty verdict last week in Illinois.

The Illinois State Police Director is commending ISP investigators and special agents in the conviction of the man found guilty of kidnapping and murdering a child 55 years ago.

On September 14, 72-year-old Jack McCullough was found guilty of murder, kidnapping, and abduction of 7-year-old Maria Ridulph. ISP says Ridulph was kidnapped and murdered in 1957.

Illinois State Police say a deathbed confession by McCullough's mother in 1994, was passed on to them by McCullough's half-sister in 2008.  Captain Tony Rapaz took the initial call that launched the ISP cold case murder investigation.  

"Every tip to law enforcement officers is taken seriously because you never know where the evidence may lead to," said ISP Captain Tony Rapaz.  "Within 2 weeks of receiving this peculiar phone call, an investigation was immediately launched."

The lead investigator, Special Agent Brion Hanley, recalls the case as being extraordinarily complicated with both families having to relive painful grief and horrible memories. 

"Without the cooperation of the families in their pursuit of justice and closure, our work as law enforcement would not be possible," said ISP Special Agent Brion Hanley. "Their memories and solid, positive identification of photos, times and locations, were just as powerful as the investigative leads that solved the case."

"These investigators did an extraordinary job in developing a timeline with powerful statements from family members and community residents that presented the facts that eventually helped convict a murderer," said ISP Director Hiram Grau. "Since 2008, they have tirelessly applied their investigative skills to this cold case by using good old fashioned police work."

Grau also underscored the importance of teamwork by DeKalb State's Attorney Clay Campbell and his team of prosecutors, Seattle Police, and the Ridulph and Tessier family members in seeking justice and closure.

Copyright 2012 WFIE. All rights reserved.